MSTR Cat

Trust Law/Level VII · Property and business/7.3 Employers and special assets/Lesson 2

Secular trusts

How a secular trust protects deferred pay from the employer’s creditors, why that protection makes the employee taxable sooner, and how it compares with a rabbi trust.

Education, not legal advice. Trust law changes from country to country and state to state, and the right structure depends on your situation. Anything you sign should be drafted or reviewed by a qualified lawyer where you live.

The lean path

The cheapest, lowest-tax, simplest and most private route the law allows, best first. Each step names the rule it rests on and the condition that keeps it lawful.

  1. The leaner way to secure deferred pay is usually a qualified plan, both protected and tax-deferred: the 2026 limits are $24,500 for 401(k) deferrals and $7,500 for IRA contributions.
  2. A secular trust taxes the employee once the interest vests, under §402(b) and §83, often before any cash arrives; plan how the tax will be paid before agreeing to one.
  3. Amounts already taxed are generally not taxed again when paid out under §402(b)(2) and §72, so keep records of each year’s inclusion to avoid paying tax twice on the same money.
  4. The employer deducts in the year the employee includes the amount (§404(a)(5)) and, with several participants, only if separate accounts are kept, so insist on separate accounts in the plan.
  5. Choose a rabbi trust instead if tax deferral matters more than insolvency protection; neither removes income tax, they only change its timing or the employee’s exposure to the employer’s creditors.

Materials26 U.S.C. §402(b), on nonexempt employees’ trusts, from law.cornell.edu26 U.S.C. §83, on property transferred in connection with services, from law.cornell.eduLesson 7.3.1, on rabbi trusts, for comparison

Wonder

  1. Why might an employee pay tax now on pay they will receive later?
  2. What happens to money in a secular trust if the employer goes bankrupt?
  3. Why are deferred pay trusts that protect employees taxed differently from trusts that leave them exposed?

Explore

  1. A secular trust is a trust that holds assets for an employee’s deferred compensation beyond the reach of the employer’s creditors. It is the opposite of a rabbi trust (lesson 7.3.1), where the assets stay reachable by those creditors. The name is an informal label chosen as a contrast with the rabbi trust; the tax rules come from the Internal Revenue Code. This lesson explains how secular trusts are taxed and does not recommend one.
  2. An employer-funded secular trust is usually a nonexempt employees’ trust, meaning it is not a qualified retirement plan trust exempt from tax under §501(a). Under §402(b)(1), employer contributions to such a trust are included in the employee’s gross income in accordance with §83. Because the assets are set aside from the employer’s creditors, the employee’s interest is ‘property’ under the §83 regulations and is taxed once it is vested, meaning transferable or no longer subject to a substantial risk of forfeiture, even though payment comes later.
  3. Distributions from the trust are taxed under §402(b)(2) and the annuity rules of §72 in the year they are paid or made available, so amounts already taxed are generally not taxed again. A special rule in §402(b)(4) applies to highly compensated employees when the trust is nonexempt because the plan fails certain coverage or participation tests: they include their vested accrued benefit in income. The trust’s own earnings may also be taxed, and the details depend on how the trust is set up.
  4. The employer’s deduction follows the employee’s tax. Under §404(a)(5), an employer contributing to a nonqualified plan deducts the amount in the year it is included in the employees’ income, and where more than one employee takes part, only if separate accounts are kept for each. With a rabbi trust, the employer generally deducts only when the pay is made and included in the employee’s income, and it is taxed on the trust’s earnings in the meantime because the trust is a grantor trust.
  5. The trade-off is security against tax timing. Secular trust assets are not available to the employer’s general creditors, so the employee’s deferred pay is protected if the employer becomes insolvent, which a rabbi trust does not do. But the employee is taxed when the interest vests, often before any cash is received. Practitioner sources describe secular trusts as rarely used for this reason, and rabbi trusts as far more common.
  6. Side by side: in a rabbi trust, the assets are reachable by the employer’s creditors, the employee is taxed when paid, and the employer is taxed on the trust’s earnings and deducts when it pays. In a secular trust, the assets are beyond those creditors, the employee is taxed when the interest vests under §402(b) and §83, and the employer’s deduction follows that inclusion. Which kind a trust is depends on its terms, especially whether creditors can reach the assets.

Key facts

  • A secular trust holds assets for an employee’s deferred pay beyond the reach of the employer’s general creditors.
  • Under §402(b)(1), employer contributions to a nonexempt employees’ trust are included in the employee’s income in accordance with §83.
  • Under §83, the employee is generally taxed once the interest is transferable or no longer subject to a substantial risk of forfeiture, even before payment.
  • Distributions from a secular trust are taxed under §402(b)(2) and §72; §402(b)(4) taxes certain highly compensated employees on their vested accrued benefit.
  • Under §404(a)(5), the employer’s deduction for nonqualified deferred pay is generally taken when the amount is included in the employee’s income.
  • A secular trust protects the employee if the employer becomes insolvent, unlike a rabbi trust, but earlier taxation is why practitioner sources say it is rarely used.

Exercise nine, six, three, one

9CollectList up to 9 features of a deferred compensation trust described in this lesson or a source you are reading (some sources give fewer), such as who funds it, whether creditors can reach the assets, when the employee is taxed and when the employer deducts.
6ClusterSort them into 6 categories: funding, creditors’ access, the employee’s tax, the employer’s tax, payment timing, and facts you are unsure about.
3DistillReduce the 6 categories to 3 groups: features of a secular trust, features of a rabbi trust, and features shared by both.
1CrystallizeWrite 1 sentence explaining, in your own words, why protecting deferred pay from the employer’s creditors makes it taxable to the employee sooner.

Fact check

Dates, figures and claims checked against the published sources listed below.

Open in the interactive academy →

PT ES ZH JA KO RU DE FR MS